See All Articles

The Pellet Gun of Denial: How the Government Shoots Its Young Citizens and Then Lies About It

If you have been watching the protests against paper leaks and the collapse of the education system, you would have seen the videos. You would have seen young men and women, hands tied with cloth, surrounded by police, dragged, beaten, and yes, shot at. The Delhi Police insisted no pellet gun was used. But the journalists did their job. And when the truth came out, the government’s only response was to stop talking. Silence is not innocence; it is the most brutal form of guilt.

The Initial Denial and Media’s Persistence

When The Hindu published its first report by Vijaita Singh and Ashna Butani, documenting the use of pellet guns against protesters, the Delhi Police immediately took to Twitter. Under the news article’s link, they wrote a single line: “Pellet gun ka istemaal nahin hua hai” – pellet guns were not used. That was the government’s strategy: deny, dismiss, and hope the story disappears. But it didn’t.

The journalists did not budge. The Hindu stood by its report. Then came more: Scroll’s Ayush Tiwari, Newslaundry’s Avdhesh Kumar, Article 14’s Saba Gurmat, The Wire’s Vipul Kumar, Times of India’s Neha Mishra, India Today’s Anand Singh. Each of them filed stories confirming that the Rapid Action Force (RAF) had indeed fired pellet guns. One report even mentioned that an Outlook journalist was hit by pellets, though his name was withheld. Journalist Mohammed Zubair shared a video of a protester showing pellet marks on his body. Independent journalists like Sachin Gupta also documented the injuries. The police’s lie was now surrounded by a wall of evidence.

Police’s Shifting Narrative: From Denial to “Verification”

Once the newspapers started carrying the stories, the Delhi Police changed its approach. They stopped the outright denial and instead began claiming that they were “verifying” the media reports. This is a classic Modi-government technique: when caught, pretend that you are investigating the truth, but never reveal it. The press note said they were looking into claims that the RAF used pellet guns. But hold on: the RAF is a paramilitary force under the Union Home Ministry. Does the Delhi Police not know what ammunition its own forces carry? Does the CRPF not maintain a strict log of every bullet, every cartridge issued? As journalist Sushant Singh pointed out, every force keeps a full record of which jawans are given what weapons. The RAF unit and the CRPF director general know exactly who fired the pellet guns and on whose orders. This information is not being hidden because it’s unknown. It is being hidden because the Prime Minister’s office wants it hidden.

Rahul Gandhi’s Intervention: Holding the Bullet to the Government’s Face

Then came a moment that the so-called “Godi media” would rather forget. Rahul Gandhi, the Leader of Opposition, held a press conference and brought with him a young man whose eye had been damaged by a pellet gun. He showed the injury, the visible proof, and directly challenged the government. “Ye hamare future hain ... inki aankh se dikhayi nahi de raha hai,” he said. These are our future. He cannot see from his eye. The government had shot its own youth in the eyes, and still, the Home Minister did not utter a word. No press conference, no explanation, no accountability.

Rahul Gandhi did what the media should have done long ago: he physically dragged the truth into the newsrooms that had ignored it. He held the proof up to the cameras, to journalists, to the empty chairs where the government’s representatives should have been sitting. He forced the conversation back to the pellet guns, back to the brutality, back to the question no one in power wants to answer: who gave the order to fire on students?

The Story of Sahil: One Eye, a Father’s Hope, a Government’s Failure

The Indian Express reported the case of Sahil Lochab, a student of Delhi University’s School of Open Learning. He took part in the protest on July 20, exhausted and frustrated. He had filled the form for the Delhi Police recruitment exam in 2024, but the exam was cancelled because the paper was leaked. He came out to protest, and a pellet fired from a police weapon hit his right eye. He is now being treated at AIIMS. Doctors have confirmed the injury was caused by a pellet gun. His vision is weak, and there is a risk that he may lose his eyesight completely. His father is a deep driver; his family lives in Najafgarh. The state’s ammunition has shattered a poor family’s dreams. All because the government cannot conduct a fair examination.

This is not an isolated incident. Counsel and injuries have been reported from multiple protest sites. The Indian Express, again, stood apart by naming the victim and telling the story. The government remained silent.

The Crumbling Education System and the Shame of NTA

Why are these young people on the streets? Because the education system under this government has become a machine for crushing hope. Look at the National Testing Agency (NTA), the body responsible for conducting major exams like NEET-UG. The data, provided by Union Minister of State for Education Sukanta Majumdar in the Rajya Sabha, is damning. Out of 39 sanctioned posts, 15 are vacant. The NTA operates with just 24 permanent employees, while 197 are on contract. Let that sink in.

NTA Workforce Details	Number
Sanctioned Posts	39
Vacant Posts	15
Permanent Employees	24
Contractual Employees	197

More than 20 lakh students appear for NEET-UG every year. Their futures are decided by an agency that runs largely on temporary contracts. The same agency that cancelled the UGC-NET exam a day after it was conducted, citing a leak. The same agency that saw the CSIR-UGC NET postponed. The same pattern: leak, cancellation, protest, lathi charge, pellet gun. Students who toiled for years, whose parents spent their savings on coaching and dreams, are told at the last minute that their papers have been leaked, that someone with 60-70 lakh rupees bought the paper, and that their hard work means nothing. And when they dare to ask questions, they are met with bullets.

Dharmendra Pradhan, the Education Minister, is not just a failure; he is a symbol of the collapse. As the protesters demanded in one voice, he has to go. He is the reason a young man’s eye was shot. He is the reason thousands are standing outside in the heat and rain. Yet, he continues to hold his chair, and the Prime Minister continues to protect him. The government that promised ‘Sabka Saath, Sabka Vikas’ has delivered ‘Sabka Paper Leak, Sabka Net Future’.

The Government’s Strategy: Brutal Suppression and a Chilling Warning

The use of pellet guns is not a mistake; it is a message. The state is telling its young citizens: come out, and you will lose your eyes. In Jammu and Kashmir, pellet guns blinded hundreds, partially or fully. Now the same technique is being deployed in the streets of Delhi. Lathis embedded with nails are being used. Water cannons are hurled like weapons. The intention is clear – to break not just bones but the will to resist. This government wants to pre-empt every future protest by showing what happens to those who dissent. Cameras with facial recognition have been installed around protest sites, violating the privacy of thousands who might not even know they are being watched. The message is: we will identify you, we will beat you, and we will blind you if necessary. Do not step out.

The Global Contrast: Shame in the Eyes of the World

While Indian students and people of Indian origin are raising their voices from Sydney to Vancouver, standing in solidarity with the protestors back home, the Delhi government responds with force. The picture from Sydney shows peaceful protesters holding banners. Here in Delhi, the picture shows bloodied eyes. The world is watching. The government hides behind “verification” and continues to stonewall any genuine inquiry. This is not just a law-and-order problem; it is a moral collapse of the state. When a government shoots its own unarmed youth, it forfeits every claim to legitimacy.

The Missing Accountability: Who Will Answer?

The Home Minister, Amit Shah, has not held a single press conference. The Police Commissioner has not faced the media. No FIR has been filed against the policemen who fired the pellets. No compensation has been announced for the injured. No apology has been issued. The institutions that are supposed to protect us have become opaque walls of denial. The Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, whose signature style is to never directly answer a difficult question, has perfected the art of silence. But silence is complicity. The media, especially the so-called “Godi channels,” have largely ignored the story, choosing to amplify distractions instead of asking the difficult questions: why were pellet guns used? Who gave the order? What will happen to Sahil’s eye? What will happen to the thousands of other victims?

The truth is simple: the Modi government has waged a war on its own children. It has failed to provide fair examinations, failed to stop rampant leaks, and then failed to tolerate the protest that naturally followed. The pellet gun is not a tool of law enforcement; it is a tool of political repression. The government must stop lying. The nation demands answers. But in this regime, answers are a luxury the people can no longer afford.

Criticisms

• The Modi government is condemned for deploying pellet guns against unarmed student protesters in Delhi.
• The Delhi Police are criticized for repeatedly denying the use of pellet guns despite overwhelming video and medical evidence.
• The Union Home Ministry is faulted for failing to order an independent inquiry into the violence against students.
• Prime Minister Narendra Modi is blamed for maintaining a systematic culture of silence and denial that shields perpetrators of state violence.
• Home Minister Amit Shah is held accountable for the absence of a press conference or any public statement on the injuries inflicted on protesters.
• Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan is denounced as a symbol of the collapsed examination system and for presiding over repeated paper leaks that drove students to protest.
• The National Testing Agency (NTA) is exposed as a dysfunctional body operating with only 24 permanent staff while handling examinations for over 20 lakh aspirants.
• The Rapid Action Force (RAF) is accused of using excessive force, including pellet guns, without clear command accountability.
• The compliant “Godi media” are faulted for ignoring or underreporting the pellet gun violence and failing to ask direct questions of the government.
• The government’s record-keeping systems are implicated in a deliberate cover-up, as ammunition logs are withheld to obscure who ordered the shooting.
• Facial recognition surveillance around protest sites is condemned as a direct attack on citizens’ privacy and a tool to intimidate future demonstrators.
• The BJP-led administration is indicted for converting educational failures into a pretext for brutal physical repression of the youth.