Detained for Speaking Bengali? Gurugram’s Language Crackdown Raises Alarms

See All Articles

5 Key Takeaways

• Men in Gurugram's 'Holding Centres' claim they are detained solely for speaking Bengali.
• Detentions raise concerns about discrimination based on language and ethnicity.
• Authorities have not provided clear reasons for the detentions.
• The situation highlights broader issues of migrant rights and treatment in India.
• Human rights groups are calling for transparency and fair treatment of detainees.

Title: Why Are Bengali-Speaking Men Being Detained in Gurugram?
Recently, a troubling story has come out of Gurugram, a city near Delhi known for its modern buildings and booming businesses. According to reports from The Wire, several men have been detained in what are called ‘Holding Centres’—essentially temporary detention facilities. The reason? Many of these men say they were picked up simply because they were speaking Bengali.
Let’s break down what’s happening.
What Are ‘Holding Centres’?
Holding Centres are places where authorities keep people who they suspect might be living in India without proper documents. The idea is to check their papers and decide what to do next. But in Gurugram, it seems that the process is not always fair or transparent.
Why Were These Men Detained?
The men in question say they were not doing anything illegal. They were going about their daily lives—working, commuting, or just talking with friends. The only thing that made them stand out was their language. Bengali is spoken by millions in India, especially in West Bengal and parts of Assam and Tripura. But in Gurugram, speaking Bengali apparently made these men targets for police checks.
Some of the men told reporters that the police stopped them, asked for their identity papers, and when they couldn’t immediately produce them, they were taken away. Many of them are daily wage workers, meaning they earn money for each day they work. Being detained not only causes stress and fear, but also means they lose out on their earnings.
Is This Legal?
India’s laws do allow authorities to check for proper documents, especially in cases where someone is suspected of being an illegal immigrant. However, detaining people just because of the language they speak is not right. It raises serious questions about discrimination and fairness.
What’s the Bigger Issue?
This situation highlights a bigger problem: how easy it is for people to be targeted based on their language, appearance, or background. Many of those detained say they have lived and worked in Gurugram for years. Some even have valid documents but were not given a chance to show them.
What Can Be Done?
Human rights groups and lawyers are calling for more transparency and better treatment of those in Holding Centres. They say that everyone deserves to be treated fairly, no matter what language they speak.
In the end, this story is a reminder that India’s diversity should be celebrated, not punished. Speaking Bengali—or any language—should never be a reason for suspicion or detention.

Read more

Mistaken Identity: How Haryana’s Migrant Crackdown Is Detaining Indian Citizens

See All Articles

5 Key Takeaways

• The Punjab and Haryana High Court questioned Haryana's migrant verification process after Indian citizens were wrongly detained as illegal immigrants.
• In July, several Bengali-speaking individuals from West Bengal and Assam were held in Gurugram on suspicion of being Bangladeshi migrants but were later released after document verification.
• The court asked Haryana to submit its standard operating procedure (SOP) for verifying migrant identities by September 15, amid concerns about lack of clear guidelines.
• Petitioners argued that there is no proper verification process and that detainees faced inhuman treatment and poor communication while in custody.
• There remains no clarity on how authorities distinguish between illegal migrants and Indian citizens during such crackdowns.

When Locals Get Mistaken for Migrants: Haryana’s Policy Under the Scanner
Recently, a troubling incident in Gurugram (Gurgaon), Haryana, has put the spotlight on how authorities identify and handle suspected illegal immigrants. In July, several Bengali-speaking people were picked up by the police on suspicion of being undocumented Bangladeshi migrants. However, it turned out that many of them were actually Indian citizens from West Bengal and Assam. After their documents were checked, they were released—but not before spending time in detention.
This incident has raised serious questions about the process used to identify illegal migrants. A petition was filed in the Punjab and Haryana High Court by Nirmal Gorana, a Delhi resident, who argued that neither Haryana nor Punjab has a clear and fair system for verifying the identity of people detained during such crackdowns. The petition claims that existing rules are either missing or not being followed properly, leading to innocent Indians being wrongly detained.
The Haryana government defended its actions, saying that the police were following orders from the central government. In May 2025, the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) had asked all states to set up special teams in every district to find and deport illegal Bangladeshi migrants within 30 days. Haryana’s lawyers told the court that there is a Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) for this, created by the MHA’s Foreigners Branch. However, they couldn’t confirm if this SOP is available to the public or if the police were actually using it.
The lawyer for the petitioners, Bhavpreet Singh Dhatt, pointed out that over a thousand workers were detained in Gurugram alone, many of whom had valid documents proving they were Indian citizens. He also said that people were kept in detention centers without proper communication and faced poor treatment, all because there was no clear SOP guiding the process.
The High Court has now asked the Haryana government to submit the SOP, if it exists, by September 15. The petitioner must also file a statement if they believe no such procedure exists. As of now, there is still no clear answer on how authorities are supposed to tell the difference between illegal migrants and Indian citizens during these operations.
This case highlights the need for a transparent and fair process to ensure that innocent people are not wrongly caught up in anti-migrant drives. It’s a reminder that, in the rush to enforce the law, the rights of citizens must not be overlooked.

Read more

Haryana’s Unemployment Crisis: 4 Lakh Youth Waiting for Work

See All Articles

5 Key Takeaways

• 4.04 lakh unemployed youth are registered with 65 employment exchanges across Haryana.
• Hisar district has the highest number of registered unemployed youth (41,991), while Gurugram (2,984) and Faridabad (3,221) have the lowest.
• Nine districts have more than 20,000 unemployed youth, and six districts have fewer than 10,000.
• Among the registered, 29,986 are postgraduates, 1.01 lakh are graduates, and 2.34 lakh have completed 10+2.
• 1.85 lakh youth in Haryana are currently receiving unemployment allowance from the state government.

Over 4 Lakh Unemployed Youth Registered in Haryana: A Closer Look
Unemployment is a big concern for many families, and recent data from Haryana shows just how serious the problem is. According to official numbers, more than 4.04 lakh (404,000) young people are currently registered as unemployed across the state. These figures come from the 65 employment exchanges that help connect job seekers with employers.
Which Districts Have the Most Unemployed Youth?
The numbers show that some districts are struggling more than others. Hisar tops the list with 41,991 unemployed youth, followed closely by Jind with 40,596. Bhiwani (32,789) and Kaithal (32,561) also have high numbers. On the other hand, Gurugram and Faridabad, which are known for their industries and job opportunities, have the lowest numbers—just 2,984 and 3,221 registered unemployed youth, respectively.
In total, nine districts in Haryana have more than 20,000 unemployed youth each, while six districts have fewer than 10,000.
Who Are the Unemployed?
The data also gives us an idea about the education levels of those looking for jobs. Out of the total registered:

29,986 are postgraduates (people who have completed their master’s degree or higher)
1.01 lakh (101,000) are graduates (completed college)
2.34 lakh (234,000) have finished their 12th standard (10+2)

Hisar not only has the highest overall number of unemployed youth, but also the most postgraduates (2,757), followed by Jind, Bhiwani, and Rohtak.
Unemployment Allowance
To help those who are struggling, the Haryana government is providing unemployment allowance to 1.85 lakh (185,000) young people. This information was shared in the state Assembly in response to a question by Congress MLA Geeta Bhukkal, who wanted to know more about how employment offices are working and how many people are getting this support.
What Does This Mean?
These numbers highlight the ongoing challenge of unemployment in Haryana, especially among educated youth. While some districts are doing better, many young people are still waiting for the right job opportunity. The government’s unemployment allowance is a small relief, but the bigger goal remains—creating more jobs and helping young people build their futures.
If you or someone you know is looking for work, don’t forget to register at your local employment exchange and keep an eye out for new opportunities. Let’s hope for better days ahead!

Read more

14 Years Later: Why Haryana’s Nuclear Power Dream Is Still on Hold

See All Articles

5 Key Takeaways

• North India's first nuclear power plant (GHAVP) in Haryana, conceptualized in 2009-10, has faced significant delays and is still under construction.
• The initial target to commission the first unit by 2025 has been pushed to 2031-32 due to unexpected soil conditions and other technical challenges.
• Land acquisition, environmental clearances, and local resistance caused early administrative and procedural delays, with major construction only starting in 2022.
• The project consists of two phases with four 700 MW reactors; Phase I (Units 1 & 2) is expected by 2031, and Phase II (Units 3 & 4) by 2032.
• Despite setbacks, construction has recently accelerated, with close monitoring, equipment procurement, and community/environmental initiatives underway.

Why North India’s First Nuclear Power Plant in Haryana Is Still Not Ready After 14 Years
Back in 2009-10, the idea of building north India’s first nuclear power plant in Haryana was born. The government chose Gorakhpur village in Fatehabad district as the perfect spot. The project, called the Gorakhpur Haryana Anu Vidyut Pariyojana (GHAVP), was supposed to be a big step forward for clean energy in the region.
In January 2014, former Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh even laid the foundation stone, marking the official start of the project. The plan was to have the first unit up and running by 2025. But here we are, 14 years later, and the plant is still not finished.
So, what went wrong?
First, there were the usual hurdles: buying land, getting environmental clearances, and talking to local farmers—some of whom weren’t happy about giving up their land. Even after the grand ceremony, actual construction was slow to start because of paperwork, compensation issues, and other red tape.
Between 2014 and 2021, not much happened on the ground. Then, the Covid-19 pandemic hit, causing even more delays. It wasn’t until 2022 that major construction finally began, focusing on the first phase, which includes two reactors that can each generate 700 megawatts of power.
But then, another problem popped up: the soil. The ground at the site turned out to be weaker than expected, with no hard rock underneath. This meant engineers had to come up with new ways to make the ground strong enough to support the heavy equipment. These technical challenges took a lot of time to sort out, pushing the project’s timeline even further.
Now, officials say the first two units should be ready by 2031, with the next two coming a year later. The government and the Nuclear Power Corporation of India are keeping a close eye on the project to make sure things move faster from now on. They’ve also started community programs, like planting trees and supporting local development.
In short, what was supposed to be a quick win for clean energy in north India has turned into a long, drawn-out process. But with construction finally picking up speed, there’s hope that Haryana will soon have its own nuclear power plant—just a few years later than planned.

Read more